Real or fake?

Discussions on Talking Machines of British or European Manufacture
User avatar
gramophone-georg
Victor VI
Posts: 3984
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 11:55 pm
Personal Text: Northwest Of Normal
Location: Eugene/ Springfield Oregon USA

Real or fake?

Post by gramophone-georg »

Happened to stumble across this on eBay. I'm posting it here rather than in the eBay section because it's a Euro machine.

First- Is it genuine? The wood, box design, decal, arm, and brake give me pause. Yet, on the whole, it seems well built.

If it's real, what model and era is it?

Thanks!

http://www.ebay.com/itm/152393398042?_t ... EBIDX%3AIT
"He who dies with the most shellac wins"- some nutty record geek

I got PTSD from Peter F's avatar

User avatar
Henry
Victor V
Posts: 2624
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:01 am
Location: Allentown, Pennsylvania

Re: Real or fake?

Post by Henry »

Fake. What you listed, and the sound box is not Victor.

User avatar
gramophone-georg
Victor VI
Posts: 3984
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 11:55 pm
Personal Text: Northwest Of Normal
Location: Eugene/ Springfield Oregon USA

Re: Real or fake?

Post by gramophone-georg »

Henry wrote:Fake. What you listed, and the sound box is not Victor.
I figured the sound box part was so obvious I didn't mention it.
"He who dies with the most shellac wins"- some nutty record geek

I got PTSD from Peter F's avatar

User avatar
Curt A
Victor Monarch Special
Posts: 6412
Joined: Fri Jul 09, 2010 8:32 pm
Personal Text: Needle Tins are Addictive
Location: Belmont, North Carolina

Re: Real or fake?

Post by Curt A »

I'm not sure exactly what this machine is, since it is European, but I don't think it's fake... The back bracket, tonearm and elbow look like an English Victor product. I'm sure someone can identify it...
Attachments
s-l1600.jpg
s-l1600 (1).jpg
"The phonograph† is not of any commercial value."
Thomas Alva Edison - Comment to his assistant, Samuel Insull.

"No one needs a Victrola XX, a Perfected Graphophone Type G, or whatever you call those noisy things."
My Wife

CarlosV
Victor IV
Posts: 1835
Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:18 am
Location: Luxembourg

Re: Real or fake?

Post by CarlosV »

Could be a Swiss machine, with a fake dog decal. The brake is a generic part used in many Swiss and German second tier manufacturers.

User avatar
gramophone-georg
Victor VI
Posts: 3984
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 11:55 pm
Personal Text: Northwest Of Normal
Location: Eugene/ Springfield Oregon USA

Re: Real or fake?

Post by gramophone-georg »

CarlosV wrote:Could be a Swiss machine, with a fake dog decal. The brake is a generic part used in many Swiss and German second tier manufacturers.
The dog decal looks like a variant of a Victor Talking Machine horn decal. I can make out the 'king' of the second word. I doubt it's in any way original. Plus it looks like a pine box... or am I mistaken? Did German/ Swiss HMV variants use pine?

I don't think I'll bid on it but I want to learn more about what is correct and what isn't on these machines. I really don't think it's a complete fake, either... but I am keeping an open mind. Maybe it's a Franken rather than a fake? The arm and backrest construction seem too good to be a fake. I've just never seen this style before.

Could it be some sort of Zonophone?
"He who dies with the most shellac wins"- some nutty record geek

I got PTSD from Peter F's avatar

Phonofreak
Victor VI
Posts: 3718
Joined: Tue Mar 23, 2010 7:00 pm
Location: Western, WA State

Re: Real or fake?

Post by Phonofreak »

This is not a Victor/HMV product. This is a legitimate Swiss, German or British machine from about 1910-20. The case, bracket, elbow, arm are the give aways. The dog decal on the case is not correct. The reproducer looks like a Thorens from the 1920-30 period. With a fluted peacock horn and a European mica reproducer, it would be a very attractive machine.
Harvey Kravitz

User avatar
gramophone-georg
Victor VI
Posts: 3984
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 11:55 pm
Personal Text: Northwest Of Normal
Location: Eugene/ Springfield Oregon USA

Re: Real or fake?

Post by gramophone-georg »

Harvey- is the wood the box is made of correct? The reason I was thinking HMV was the turntable, speed control, and the crank.

I agree it could be an attractive machine. I've seen other HMV machines, specifically a Monarch, from this seller and they seemed to check out OK given the other photos and info I could find on them. This one threw me, though.
"He who dies with the most shellac wins"- some nutty record geek

I got PTSD from Peter F's avatar

User avatar
zipcord
Victor I
Posts: 166
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2016 9:03 pm
Location: Albany, CA

Re: Real or fake?

Post by zipcord »


Phonofreak
Victor VI
Posts: 3718
Joined: Tue Mar 23, 2010 7:00 pm
Location: Western, WA State

Re: Real or fake?

Post by Phonofreak »

gramophone-georg wrote:Harvey- is the wood the box is made of correct? The reason I was thinking HMV was the turntable, speed control, and the crank.

I agree it could be an attractive machine. I've seen other HMV machines, specifically a Monarch, from this seller and they seemed to check out OK given the other photos and info I could find on them. This one threw me, though.

The wood on the case is correct. It was either Oak, or some other European hardwood. At a glance, it looks like an HMV/ Victor machine. The speed control, crank, turntable and brake are typical of these types of European machines. These machines were Victor/HMV knock-offs made in Germany, Switzerland, British or French. I have this same machine in Oak. It's packed away right now. It has a 2 spring motor and a 12" cast iron turntable. The price is very high for what is shown. If it had the correct reproducer and horn, then the price wouldn't be so bad.
Harvey Kravitz

Post Reply