Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Discussions on Talking Machines of British or European Manufacture
Post Reply
New Yorker
Victor Jr
Posts: 37
Joined: Fri May 05, 2017 8:41 pm

Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Post by New Yorker »

Compared to other portables, the HMV 102 is obviously a superb sounding machine, both in frequency response and volume. I’ve never heard any of the full-size Orthophonic machines, like the Credenza (except, of course, on Youtube, where I’ve heard it many times). So... how does it compare?

CarlosV
Victor IV
Posts: 1835
Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:18 am
Location: Luxembourg

Re: Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Post by CarlosV »

New Yorker wrote:Compared to other portables, the HMV 102 is obviously a superb sounding machine, both in frequency response and volume. I’ve never heard any of the full-size Orthophonic machines, like the Credenza (except, of course, on Youtube, where I’ve heard it many times). So... how does it compare?
There is no comparison, it is another league. The best portable (and the HMV 102 is one of the best) does not even come close to the quality of a good cabinet machine. A matter of physics: horns need to have minimum dimensions well above those of the portables to be able to reproduce lower frequencies

OrthoFan
Victor V
Posts: 2178
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2016 7:12 pm

Re: Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Post by OrthoFan »

CarlosV wrote:There is no comparison, it is another league. The best portable (and the HMV 102 is one of the best) does not even come close to the quality of a good cabinet machine. A matter of physics: horns need to have minimum dimensions well above those of the portables to be able to reproduce lower frequencies
Having owned both a Credenza and HMV 102, I'd say it's like comparing a good quality table radio with a five inch speaker to full size radio equipped with a ten inch speaker. (In both cases, AM monaural.)

For starters, in spite of the fact that the HMV 102 pumps out a strong lower mid-range and crisp treble, there's really no bass. With a Credenza -- one that's had both the sound box and tone chamber properly overhauled -- you not only hear the bass, but you feel it as well--depending on the listening room's acoustic conditions. Also, the Credenza has a far more expanded sound quality.

The major reason for this is the fact that, while both are fitted with exponentially tapered tone chambers, the Credenza's is twice as long -- six feet from the sound box to the horn's mouth.

While this is an entirely different gramophone -- these two videos illustrate the type of difference --

An HMV 31 fitted with a standard horn and EMG 2-spring sound box -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EO4v99CVu_w
An HMV 31, playing the same record, but fitted with an EMG Oversize horn -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9P1trPQYh_s

OrthoFan

estott
Victor Monarch
Posts: 4172
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:23 pm
Personal Text: I have good days...this might not be one of them
Location: Albany NY

Re: Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Post by estott »

I have a VV 2-65, the closest Victor portable to the HMV 102. It has excellent sound for a portable but the short tone arm and horn mean that you will never get the depth of tone and the bass response of even the smallest of the full size machines. This is no slur on these portables

New Yorker
Victor Jr
Posts: 37
Joined: Fri May 05, 2017 8:41 pm

Re: Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Post by New Yorker »

Thanks for these insightful replies. Looks like a Credenza - or similar Orthophonic machine – might be in my future. Assuming I move somewhere with more space than my little 1-bdrm apartment!

User avatar
SteveM
Victor II
Posts: 329
Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2013 2:20 pm
Location: Boyertown, PA
Contact:

Re: Sound quality: HMV 102 vs full-size machines

Post by SteveM »

I'll never ever forget the day I took my HMV 102 to Skip Kahl's place. He hadn't heard one before, and I had never heard a Credenza. The look on his face before he dropped the needle ... "I'm about to blow your mind." And it really did. I wish I had the space for one.
“The cup of tea on arrival at a country house is a thing which, as a rule, I particularly enjoy. I like the crackling logs, the shaded lights, the scent of buttered toast, the general atmosphere of leisured cosiness.”

P. G. Wodehouse

Post Reply