Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Discussions on Talking Machines & Accessories
Post Reply
User avatar
Jonsheff
Victor II
Posts: 286
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2018 11:16 pm
Personal Text: Let's make Victrolas Great Again!
Location: Manchester Connecticut
Contact:

Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by Jonsheff »

I saw this nice looking Victrola 18 on ebay listed as all original condition but it looks to me like someone stripped it and stained it with minwax mahogany with poly satin clear coat. You can see the darker original finish on the carvings and other areas where they missed sanding or stripping. Also pretty obvious difference between the top underside and inside storage.and the outsides.
Does anyone else agree?
Screenshot_20191115-201714_eBay.jpg
Screenshot_20191115-192144_eBay.jpg

User avatar
barnettrp21122
Victor IV
Posts: 1600
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 4:19 pm
Personal Text: "Did you ever stop to think that pleasure is a duty?" (Victor sales pamphlet)

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by barnettrp21122 »

Yes, I agree. Too bad.
Bob
"Comparison is the thief of joy" Theodore Roosevelt

His Master's Voice Automatic 1A Exponential Gramophone Demonstration:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi70G1Rzqpo

User avatar
Skihawx
Victor III
Posts: 968
Joined: Fri Aug 20, 2010 7:48 am
Location: New Hampshire

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by Skihawx »

Looks refinished. I saw it at the original auction and it was even advertised as nicely restored finish.

https://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/76 ... phonograph

User avatar
audiophile102
Victor IV
Posts: 1219
Joined: Tue May 12, 2015 12:50 pm
Personal Text: Say to yourself I am so happy hurray!
Location: Brookfield, Illinois

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by audiophile102 »

Ebay will take the side of the buyer who complains that the item purchased was misrepresented so if you know who the seller is, you might let them know to correct the description.
"You can't take the phonographs nor the money with you, but the contentment the phonographs bring may well make your life better, and happier lives make the world a better place."

User avatar
AZ*
Victor IV
Posts: 1143
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2009 8:51 pm
Location: USA

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by AZ* »

There's another one on ebay, item 163805785829, that is also claimed to have original finish. It looks better, but I am suspicious that it may not be completely original either. I would guess that it has been possibly re-amalgamated, with additional coats of shellac and buffed. It looks too good to be true for 100 years old. What do you think? :?:
Best regards ... AZ*

User avatar
Phonolair
Victor III
Posts: 597
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:23 pm
Location: Michigan

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by Phonolair »

Yes I agree also, definitely refinished. I'm surprised the seller would state otherwise.

AZ* wrote:There's another one on ebay, item 163805785829, that is also claimed to have original finish. It looks better, but I am suspicious that it may not be completely original either. I would guess that it has been possibly re-amalgamated, with additional coats of shellac and buffed. It looks too good to be true for 100 years old. What do you think? :?:
This one on eBay looks much better. Although the seller doesn't state in his description the finish has been restored. In his video he does state the finish has been restored. So it's still misleading, you shouldn't have to dig for every bit of information.

Larry Crandell

User avatar
Jonsheff
Victor II
Posts: 286
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2018 11:16 pm
Personal Text: Let's make Victrolas Great Again!
Location: Manchester Connecticut
Contact:

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by Jonsheff »

AZ* wrote:There's another one on ebay, item 163805785829, that is also claimed to have original finish. It looks better, but I am suspicious that it may not be completely original either. I would guess that it has been possibly re-amalgamated, with additional coats of shellac and buffed. It looks too good to be true for 100 years old. What do you think? :?:
I have seen that one before, definitely a poly clear coat, also wrong stain color (looks like minwax mahogany) and wrong sheen, most likely minwax satin poly. Too bad, a correct restore and that one would have been beautiful. You can tell a sloppy restore like this one by looking at the carvings and feet, they didn't bother to remove the original finish so they are much darker than the rest.
It take a lot of time and meticulous effort to get the details to come out right.

VanEpsFan1914
Victor VI
Posts: 3165
Joined: Fri Oct 06, 2017 11:39 am
Personal Text: I've got both kinds of music--classical & rag-time.
Location: South Carolina

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by VanEpsFan1914 »

Will you be the one putting the time and details into it, or have they effectively ruined two old machines by charging too much for them? I don't know how much your kind of work costs but it can't be a cheap or casual job.

User avatar
FloridaClay
Victor VI
Posts: 3708
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:14 pm
Location: Merritt Island, FL

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by FloridaClay »

Just as a general observation it is not at all unusual to observe a difference is color between the inside of a machine and the outside as exteriors can get lightened by exposure to sun light.

Clau
Arthur W. J. G. Ord-Hume's Laws of Collecting
1. Space will expand to accommodate an infinite number of possessions, regardless of their size.
2. Shortage of finance, however dire, will never prevent the acquisition of a desired object, however improbable its cost.

zenith82
Victor II
Posts: 318
Joined: Mon Dec 30, 2013 1:46 pm
Location: Baltimore, MD

Re: Is this Victrola 18 original condition?

Post by zenith82 »

FloridaClay wrote:Just as a general observation it is not at all unusual to observe a difference is color between the inside of a machine and the outside as exteriors can get lightened by exposure to sun light.

Clau
That's true, though machines that fall into this category usually have a washed-out looking appearance instead of sharply contrasting veneer colors on the exterior.

The machine in question in this thread is obviously a poor to mediocre refinish. If anything good can be said, it doesn't look like it was a recent act. It wouldn't surprise me if it was refinished 20-30 years ago.

Post Reply