The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Discussions on Talking Machines & Accessories
Post Reply
User avatar
long_island_phono
Victor II
Posts: 394
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2013 1:58 am

The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Post by long_island_phono »

For those unaware, I love the thrill of the chase. I am 30 and have been mesmerized by early audio tecnhology and accessories since age 9 and am relentless in my search for the early, the obscure, and the unusual. Today I present my latest find, one that I happened upon by chance while pursuing another desirable phonograph.

I, like other humans -especially your local antique/phono dealer- am prone to hyperbole. I have jumped to many conclusions over the years, some right, some half-right, and many wrong. I want to jump to a big conclusion with this Triumph and perhaps others here on the forum can help justify it. Today I will be using the “P-word,” so if you are easily offended by phono-arrogance, here’s your chance to jump ship.

By all appearances this is an early production Model A Triumph ( serial # 31,845) straight from the production line. Modifications to the topworks, a lack of cabinet decal, and some curious holes in the casting have lead me to believe that this might be...a Prototype (the P-word). Not necessarily a prototype machine, rather a workshop/tester phonograph for prototype 2/4 minute gearing and maybe a repeater designed by Edison employee and inventor Peter Weber (P-word 2.0).

This Triumph has a working 2/4 minute gearing attachment, consisting of a secondary feedscrew and corresponding feed nut, and tracks accurately for both thread pitches. It has a sliding feed nut assembly to switch between the two settings.


First clue: There is no decal on the cabinet. The cabinet has been entirely coated in varnish. I removed the bedplate and the varish went clear to the inside edge of the top frame. You can see sections of the original finish where the varish stuck to the bedplate when it was still wet. Also, note the grain filler and shellac is still visible under varnish with no sign of a decal being present.

Second clue: Machined and threaded holes in back of topworks casting. These holes are shifted to the left from where the final production Weber repeater worm gear stanchions are mounted. Squarish ghosts of something around the holes. Weber repeaters have architecture screwed to the front of the casting as well.... something to consider.

Third clue: Mysterious hole to the right of the front casting mounting bolt. Small squarish ghost around this hole.

Fourth clue: a somewhat rough clamp/armature that holds the 4-minute feedscrew in place. Feedscrew looks like a Type Q or Standard feedscrew but is in fact different in both thread pitch and diameter. I have compared to various Edison and Graphophone models with no matches. The 4-minute feedscrew gear, however, does appear to be a Type Q motor pulley. It has radiating etched lines that appear to indicate the measuring of teeth. James Ott, another Edison “right hand man,” was also working on 2/4-minute gearing, including gearing for Graphophones. I’d assume Edison phono works employees had Graphophone machines and parts for reference purposes.

Fifth clue: Custom cast and fitted mandrel shaft drive gear for 4-minute feedscrew. Here’s where it gets interesting. As you see below, this is a unique casting with machined or cast gear teeth. The casting has two arms with different ends that fit over the end of the mandrel shaft, which has been modified accordingly. This indicates to me a larger scale fabrication shop than your typical local machinist would have.
***Also note that the Weber repeater used a drive gear in the same location.

Sixth clue: A more intentionally designed feed nut spring assembly that features a slotted spring that allows for the sliding feed nut piece to move between 2 and 4-minute operation. The slot is perfectly cut, so sliding the feed nuts all the way back engages 4-minute and all the way to the front, 2-minute.

Seventh clue: Patent drawings from January of 1908 submitted by Peter Weber showing a nearly identical 2/4 minute gearing setup, save for the drawings having a more sophisticated “rocker” selector for each feed nut.

https://patentimages.storage.googleapis ... 932202.pdf




What do you think?

-Jake
Attachments
60133156-E8DD-443B-92D7-1696BB31DB9A.jpeg
0EED2125-6D16-4B12-B261-3C8F3FDFCC8D.jpeg
D47EE7AE-EE0B-401B-8FF5-0D32113B3F43.jpeg
30E12F73-6EE9-4A74-9702-382ED8260FF5.jpeg
9D049445-C7F9-457B-ACA4-E495F5012AA1.jpeg
E7AE5F2C-ED8D-465B-AB73-37659FECD48B.jpeg
7AD3990E-BEAA-4A82-BAF9-B0A60F791EC7.jpeg
1B65A85E-19B3-4ECC-A130-E3736DC9F09D.jpeg
5BE425EB-D81E-4B57-B84E-307974BBA099.jpeg
Last edited by long_island_phono on Thu Nov 29, 2018 10:03 pm, edited 8 times in total.

User avatar
long_island_phono
Victor II
Posts: 394
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2013 1:58 am

Re: The “P” Word

Post by long_island_phono »

Additional photos.
Attachments
19E5BC9B-C7FC-4F31-B050-98C7866AECB6.jpeg
D7FECC9A-76C9-47BE-9E13-BB4AD7C55ACD.jpeg
77CC5028-CB3C-4A05-98CA-02E9DA9FDCAB.jpeg
C4BBF613-17EE-4EA1-AE23-9E4DB9E47E01.jpeg
874184A8-EB92-4703-9D0A-F4AD35FFBA05.jpeg
8561D302-CA70-4275-88CE-21B351B1A73C.jpeg
4C876540-7F08-41BF-AC56-B983E3DB153F.jpeg
97D83596-B6EA-46E3-AFC4-353A4718D636.jpeg

User avatar
long_island_phono
Victor II
Posts: 394
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2013 1:58 am

Re: The “P” Word

Post by long_island_phono »

And more photos.
Attachments
EEE0CC0E-69C3-4C32-9D31-E86C1A510353.jpeg
4BB2BB28-0BFD-45BA-9A69-B8D2F9E2D2E4.jpeg
36420414-3608-4C6F-99D8-534E16CCBEEE.jpeg
497305A6-2246-4EC3-AD0A-9F8A1F73A075.jpeg

gsphonos
Victor II
Posts: 380
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:33 pm

Re: The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Post by gsphonos »

Neat machine!! Thanks for sharing!

Mike Sorter
Riverside, CA

User avatar
Lucius1958
Victor VI
Posts: 3935
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 12:17 am
Location: Where there's "hamburger ALL OVER the highway"...

Re: The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Post by Lucius1958 »

Quite a find! Any provenance behind it?

Might be worth contacting the Edison Historical Site about this... :geek:

Bill

User avatar
long_island_phono
Victor II
Posts: 394
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2013 1:58 am

Re: The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Post by long_island_phono »

Lucius1958 wrote:Quite a find! Any provenance behind it?

Might be worth contacting the Edison Historical Site about this... :geek:

Bill
I wish. According to the shop owner where I picked it up, some house cleaner brought it in. Who knows where it has been. Someone fashioned a crank by drilling out a threaded Standard/Home crank and hammering 4 sides to it. It did not come with a reproducer so no clues in that department.

-Jake

User avatar
fmblizz
Victor IV
Posts: 1171
Joined: Tue Jan 12, 2010 4:59 pm
Location: South Jersey

Re: The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Post by fmblizz »

why are all the pictures no longer available, is anyone else having problems seeing the pictures in this thread??

blizz

52089
Victor VI
Posts: 3745
Joined: Mon Oct 03, 2011 7:54 pm

Re: The “P” Word: An Unusual Edison Cylinder Phonograph

Post by 52089 »

fmblizz wrote: Sat May 14, 2022 9:35 pm why are all the pictures no longer available, is anyone else having problems seeing the pictures in this thread??

blizz
The links to all attachments more than a year or so old have been "lost". David, the owner of the board and our technical guru, is aware of it and hopes to be able to resolve it soon, but right now he has a very full plate.

viewtopic.php?f=10&t=52726

Post Reply