estott wrote:I wasn't intending to be technical when I wrote cannon. I think that a mortar would make a pretty loud sound as well.ewok wrote:The sound reminds me of our old .60 mortars firing.
Can we be sure that the "shelling" was by cannons?
estott wrote:I've wanted to hear the shelling record- could you or someone put it on youtube?
OK, I found it online: http://acenturyofnovember.com/html/audi ... rdment.php
Not meaning any ill to Mr. Gaisberg it sounds entirely false to me- like a stroke on a bass drum and a party noisemaker. I can not believe it is real even though he says it is. Having been quite near to a black powder cannon being fired I can tell you in not only makes a tremendous noise but a sharp physical concussion. I'd expect that the needle would have jumped right off the wax, but this recording is not only clear it is TOO clear.
If I am doubting and cynical it is because a great deal of fakery was passed off as the real thing, even by the government. Crowds wept at British government sanctioned documentary THE BATTLE OF THE SOMME which contained scenes of men dying in the trenches. One prominent woman said "Now I know what my son died for". Well, all the footage was fake, shot at a training school in the UK Midlands. I can be tolerant and forgive it- this was material people really wanted to see, and I suppose it gave many of them some comfort.
gass shell mortar fiering was quite different than ordinairy mortar fiering it used less explosive than usual well you din't want to blowup the canister in the shell with the 2 chemicals that when mixed would form the deadly gass
insted the shells where propelled out of the mortar tubes like rockets thats why they make that weezing sound they did this in 2 ways 1 black powder (like fireworks)2 with compressed air
i think its compressed air beeing released here
and theres another reason why i think it was compressed air the shells would not have the same range as the black powder propelled ones so the troops fiering would often have the same fate as the enemy but only delayed
so poor william was recording the wrong type of batery and it costs his life
and another thing many victims of gass attacs would die of pneumonia and would be listed as such by medical staff
others would be listed as dying from the spanish flue it would make your lungs into mush so symtems would be confusing
gass shells are often wrongly named gass grenades this is false because the shells where quite big about the size of tank shell gass grenades did exist in WWI dough they where ball shaped objects just a bit bigger than a golf ball so basicaly the size of a regular hand grenade i gues they had the same type of box like this one in my collection it looks a bit like a cylinder box doesn't it
propelled mortars where used as far back as the war of 1812 in the battle of st louis
well thats all
greetings
tino