The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

"All of this is only my opinion and I'm more than happy to be corrected."

Tim,
I tend to agree with you - and I don't think that any correction is necessary or even possible, since any opinion or speculation is probably just as good as another on this one...
Curt

I don't think it's an Edison product the way it's configured now. I would agree it was an H19 at one time. The works has been since refitted into another cabinet and a repro Edison decal pasted under the lid.

The cabinet looks like it was built around the oak motor frame for size, and not like any H-19 to me. The mech does look like it fits very nicely in the cabinet.