Page 2 of 2

Re: The Old Fashioned Way (1934) W. C. Fields

Posted: Wed Jul 01, 2015 8:36 am
by estott
Henry wrote:
marcapra wrote:Yes, Duggan is genuinely funny, whereas Kathleen Howard is just a hen-pecking scold.
Yes, precisely---that's why I think she's funny. Something about the comic exaggeration of her haughty indignation gets to me. Example: the hilarious scene at the breakfast table in "Man on the Flying Trapeze," when she reads "another of those delightful fragments by Gertrude Smuden," an obvious reference to Gertrude Stein: "We have what we have not, and what we have not, we have. Up is down, and down---are you listening?" "[chewing mouthful of toast]"Yes, dear." "---and down is out," etc. etc. She was the perfect comic foil of a spouse for his unique brand of "hen-pecked husband" humor. BTW, Fields movies often used character names that were actual ones familiar to him from his youth, like Smuden, McGonigle, Wolfinger, etc.
Howard wrote that she and Fields got along beautifully- he could be demanding, but as a former singer she'd worked in Grand Opera with REAL Prima Donnas.