SOLD: 27" Horn possibly Columbia $150

[phonogfp]

Here's a silly vernacular inquiry. Is it pronounced Shee-ble or Sheb-lee? I've heard it both ways.

In an interview with Davidson B. Hawthorne (a grandson of Ellsworth Hawthorne) he confirmed that the surname of his grandfather's business partner was pronounced "SHEB-lee." That 1986 interview can be read on page 97 of Antique Phonograph Gadgets, Gizmos, and Gimmicks.

George P.

[bob27556]

Rich,

I can't stand the temptation any longer. Add this horn to my cart! Sold. I'll see you tomorrow.

Bob

[Phonolair]

Thanks for the very kind expressions of support (or patient understanding!). I'm clearly addicted to the history of early talking machines and related items, so I'm not likely to stop posting, but I'm painfully mindful of possible perceptions. Someone might well ask, "Who made HIM the phonograph oracle?" I don't ever want that sort of thing to get in the way of the historical record. It's a balancing act between sharing and "holding forth." I'll count on you guys to keep me on the right track.Best to all,George P.

George add me to the list of collectors that appreciate your corrections, that's how we all learn by passing on information. Misinformation doesn't do anybody any good especially in a online forum. Not everyone has the patience or skill for researching so it's good for everyone when collectors share information they are knowledgeable about.

Larry Crandell

[victorIIvictor]

George, I can only echo Larry's sentiments above, and appreciate all that I learn from the folks who post to this list.

"I imagine an earnest young collector reading something like that and eventually trying to "un-learn" it, as has happened to me so many times over the years."

Just as I will now have to try to unlearn saying "SHE-bull" after your post here! ["SHEB-lee." "SHEB-lee." "SHEB-lee." ]

Best wishes, Mark

[bob27556]

George,

As Larry stated "Not everyone has the patience or skill for researching". Many of us just don't have the time either. Please keep the education coming!

Bob