The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Posted: **Wed Nov 11, 2009 11:37 am**

WDC wrote:
Valecnik wrote:I have the Vulcan version of "Charleston" by Golden Gate Orch dubbed from a Velvetone pressing.
Bruce, I am sorry to disagree but the cylinder is dubbed from Edison Diamond Disc 51542-R. You can tell easily by the time which is exactly 4 minutes. So, after Mr. Edison refused to have it released on cylinder it would only take some 83 years until this major decision override was made.

Regarding the new diamond discs, I saw them this October too, along with a copy of a 7" Berliner. I could not tell the difference to the original as long as they were laying on the table. They're still prototypes and to my knowledge no real progress was made since the first appearance at the April show.

Norman,

I'm sure you are right. For some reason I recall that there was a reference to velvetone on the cylinder box. Now I check and it's not there??? I have no idea where I got that reference...

Posted: **Wed Nov 11, 2009 11:34 pm**

Dang, been thinking it would be cheaper to make new DDs than new cylinders and had hope someone would be able to churn out new DDs at $15-20 a copy. Alas, I need to stop being an idealist, haha.

Posted: **Thu Nov 12, 2009 3:08 pm**

Valecnik wrote:I'm sure you are right. For some reason I recall that there was a reference to velvetone on the cylinder box. Now I check and it's not there??? I have no idea where I got that reference...

I vaguely remember that someone would mention this in a thread at the old board and I would also disagree with it. Who knows...

The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Any word on the "New Diamond Discs"?

Re: Any word on the "New Diamond Discs"?

Re: Any word on the "New Diamond Discs"?

Re: Any word on the "New Diamond Discs"?