The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

The machine that tomb has is a model D. It has the recess for the clutch casing that shifts from 2 to 4 minutes, and uses the wide clutch casing of a model D
If you compare with the Model C machine you will see it is made like a model B, and uses the narrow clutch casing to clear the edge of the casting.

Wes K wrote:The machine that tomb has is a model D. It has the recess for the clutch casing that shifts from 2 to 4 minutes, and uses the wide clutch casing of a model DIf you compare with the Model C machine you will see it is made like a model B, and uses the narrow clutch casing to clear the edge of the casting.

Interesting observation, Wes. I didn't notice that until you brought it up. Considering the clutch recess seen in the Edison Home casting that Tom posted it seems odd that there is stamped C in the casting numbers. As far as I'm aware all Edison model C phonographs were factory designed for 2 minute play and therefore it seems odd that it has the 2/4 clutch recess in the casting. I suppose it's possible that the casting started out life as a model D casting and was released and stamped as a model C. As you mentioned, my (pictured) Edison Home model C does not have the recess in the casting for the clutch. Thanks for pointing this out. It will be interesting to hear from others on this.

Doug

Doug,
I think it's more likely that this started out as a model C and was converted to being a model D. If you look at that recess, it looks like it was machined rather than cast-in. The model C Home (unlike the Standard) was pretty short-lived. I'd guess that this sat around unsold until it was re-born as a model D. There are quite a few examples of Edison re-working unsold machines to move them out the door.

Regards,
Martin