EDIT: I'm referring to 20's/30's jazz bands.

I agree completely! Although I tend to think there are more exceptions than most...JerryVan wrote: Wed Sep 18, 2024 6:38 am Someone on the forum once mentioned that many/most bands do a great job with their various recordings... until someone begins to sing. I hadn't thought about it before then, but ever since, I'd have to say that I largely agree. Several excellent exceptions, of course.
Sacrilege!