Page 5 of 5
Re: Artists who recorded very well acoustically
Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 9:23 am
by schallplatte
The Youtube video is an electric recording from 1928, but Journet apparently recorded this multiple times over the years.
7 June 1909; (01064v/01066v) 032159/60
16 May 1922; (BS386-3/BS387-1) 7-32075/6
13 March 1928; (CK2790-2/CK2791-2/CK2792-2 /CK2793-1) DB1156/7
Re: Artists who recorded very well acoustically
Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 1:45 pm
by Wolfe
CarlosV wrote:
Good insight on McCormack's evolution, Rastus. As to the recordings, the discography in the (excellent)
http://www.mccormacksociety.co.uk/ shows that he recorded from the late 20's onwards in England, most frequently in the Abbey Road HMV studio.
The records he made in Abbey Road No. 3 during the war are among his best. He continued to mature as a singer even as his voice declined.
Frank Sinatra was like that - and some others. They get
better with a worn instrument.
Re: Artists who recorded very well acoustically
Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 5:59 pm
by Henry
schallplatte wrote:The Youtube video is an electric recording from 1928, but Journet apparently recorded this multiple times over the years.
7 June 1909; (01064v/01066v) 032159/60
16 May 1922; (BS386-3/BS387-1) 7-32075/6
13 March 1928; (CK2790-2/CK2791-2/CK2792-2 /CK2793-1) DB1156/7
Aha--so I thought. Bear with me, I'm learning here. I assume those numbers on the above list are not American recordings, which explains why they aren't listed in Moses.
On that 1928 recording, Journet sounds absolutely terrific. The orchestra, however, is something else again: big tuning problems here and there, especially in the woodwinds.
Re: Artists who recorded very well acoustically
Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2014 6:59 pm
by schallplatte
Henry wrote: Aha--so I thought. Bear with me, I'm learning here. I assume those numbers on the above list are not American recordings, which explains why they aren't listed in Moses.
On that 1928 recording, Journet sounds absolutely terrific. The orchestra, however, is something else again: big tuning problems here and there, especially in the woodwinds.
Yes, you're right. I didn't see these listed in my Victor discography and these appear to be European pressings. The 1928 recording is unusual. Journet's voice is splendid, but it is sung in French rather than the original German. The instrumental accompaniment is less than stellar.
Re: Artists who recorded very well acoustically
Posted: Thu Nov 06, 2014 3:07 pm
by Henry
Actually, I think I prefer it in French! (Please don't tell my forebears!).