The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Were "recording horns", like the one in the picture, made for Edison or Columbia primarily, or were they universal made by one company?

The horn pictured is not a recording horn, but a nice example of the 26" conical horn prevalent during the 1895-1900 period. (Sears was selling this type with Eagles as late as 1902.) Judging by the hanger on this one, I think it was manufactured by the Tea Tray Company. Several companies made these. There is evidence that these 26" horns were sometimes used for recording - - even by professionals - - but these were used primarily for reproduction.

Recording horns are narrower and usually not decorated.

George P.

Here is an ad for, and a couple of pictures of, two different metal recording horns. As well, there is an ad for, and a picture of, a linenoid recording horn.

You'll see all of them in future articles of "I Saw It In the Catalog" in the Antique Phonograph publication.

Shawn

I see the difference. Very helpful. These type of horns could have went on Edison Phonographs if the buyer wished? My main concern was that only Columbia used this horn on their machines.

If you mean the 26" conical horn you posted, yes - - these were used on both Edison and Columbia machines. These were not typically supplied as original equipment by either Edison or Columbia, but were popular aftermarket items for either machine.

George P.

I see. That clarifys everything. Some had told me it was strictly Columbia, but I thought the horn could be either or.

Thanks for the help George. I appreciate the clarification.