The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Here are two versions of the same song "Anything goes". First version is by top UK band Ambrose and his Orchestra and the second one of the top US bands, Paul Whiteman. But which is the better?


Ambrose Version:

http://www.box.net/shared/368f7nhc32

Paul Whiteman Version:

http://www.box.net/shared/9d7dz2yes9

RJ

Hmm, tough descission. I've always really liked the plymouth rock opening for the vocals, so I think Whiteman's vocal chorus is great, but as far as the band itself goes- Ambrose wins hands down.

Yes, I feel the same Shane. Ramona does a fantastic job with the vocals and pushes the boundaries (for the time!) by talking about nudist parties, her being naked and adults having a "baby" fettish! Nne of these references appear in the Ambrose version...which is a shame

RJ

RJ,

Here's a third vote for indecision. They both have their merits. Thank you for posting them both.

Regards,
John