The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

I am wanting to get an external horn disc machine, but my top dollar is 450-500 US. What would be a decent playing machine to look for? (I know I won't find a pristine machine at this price range). I should probably mention I already have an outside horn cylinder player (Standard B with an assortment of random horns, some homemade, some that just work)

I would try to find a Victor or Columbia. Maybe you can find one that needs some repair without a horn. Have a separate budget for the horn down the road.
Just a thought. Good luck.

An outside horn cylinder machine would be well within your budget. A disk horn machine may be a bit out of your budget unless you can find one needing some work.

My first was a Standard model A made by columbia. I love that machine, and you can pick them up in your price range. Great machines.

The above replies are good advice. For what it is worth, if you can wait a few months, the Union Show is a great source and the selection will be good.

EdiBrunsVic wrote:The above replies are good advice. For what it is worth, if you can wait a few months, the Union Show is a great source and the selection will be good.

Union is a bucket list item for sure. I'm going to try and make it this year if I don't have a reenactment and have vacation time.

I would have to sell at least one machine and probably a horn (VVIV and a less than pristine Kalamazoo Duplex horn) to both have room and have extra funds.

If you're a collector that enjoy projects buy something at a good price and enjoy the restoration journey. If that is not your cup of tea always buy the best you can afford. For example, if you are looking at a well worn $500 Triumph and a pristine $500 Edison Standard I would suggest the Standard. Years from now you'll still be pleased with the Standard and you'd always be looking for a better Triumph. Always buy the best quality you can afford.

Jerry Blais