The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Whats the average price for this model Columbia AT graphophone? Assuming there are no pot metal problems and the condition is average to good?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... 500wt_1156

The Hazelcorn book estimates the value between $450 and $600, depending on its condition. It is one of the common Columbia machines and pretty much the counterpart to Edison's Standard phonograph. But you should consider the missing horn and crank into the price. Especially early Columbia cranks are hard to find and generally reach prices above Edison cranks. If you find one, be prepared to spend another $100 for it.
You may want to look for an AT at one of the upcoming phono shows like the Wayne show on April 10th.

I was lucky to get an early AT in a square case which was only done with very few machines, here shown with a repro reproducer and horn. A assume they wanted to get rid of their stock of leftover cases from the previous Type A. The AT motor runs smooth and quiet, and has unlike the A a spring barrel.

In todays economic climate $450 to $600 for a Col AT is wishful thinking in my opinion. I think you're closer to $300.

I make no claim to expertise when valuing Columbia machines but here's a BK. The BK has no pot metal so there's no current or future problems. The AT has a slightly more attractive cabinet. The BK has a better reproducer in my opinion. Here's a nice all original and complete (crank included) BK with great decals and the price is $350. Any takers?

Jerry B. wrote:In todays economic climate $450 to $600 for a Col AT is wishful thinking in my opinion. I think you're closer to $300.

It's already at $305 with no crank and horn. When you add $100 for the crank + $150 for an original horn (if you're lucky) you'll end up at $555, shipping charge not even included.

Thanks for the feedback everyone. I agree with 3-400. Nice BK Jerry, and good price too!