The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Hello!
I received this beautiful piece as a gift from a friend, but don't know what I received, nor do I have room for it. Looking to identify it and then sell it preferably to someone who will love on this machine as it deserves and get it running beautifully.
Any assistance would be greatly appreciated!
Thank you!
Jen

Hi! I am no expert, but am happy to offer a little bit of input. Based on the photos, your Columbia Grafonola was most likely initially offered in the 1915 - 1918 time frame. It has the "slightly" upgraded option of the "record ejector system" below instead of normal shelving. Original price was $85 or so.... In the photos you attached, the phonograph appears to be complete with needle cups, original tone arm, crank, and hardware. This is a plus because many antique phonographs get "altered" over time.

In my humble opinion [and I do stress the word, humble], this forum includes many seasoned collectors who have an eye out for early or somewhat rarer machines, whereas a Columbia Grafonola of this style would fall more into a "common" or "not" rare category. I think the best market for this style of phonograph would be at a respectable local antique mall or consignment shop. In working condition, I would aim for a listing price of $250 - $275, but realistically be prepared to take less if the right person comes along. I think after negotiating with a potential buyer and offering discounts, I would expect to see a actual sale price $125 - $175.

Be careful with auction houses if you decide to go that route. Many regional local consignment style auctions will sell at no reserve and take 30 - 35% out of the final price. I have heard of antique phonographs selling for $35 and then a commission being deducted!

I hope this information helps!

[historical source: Page 134, Columbia Grafonola Companion Volume II, Robert W. Baumbach, Mac Lackey]
[pricing source: first hand experience]

Thank you so much for your thoughtful response! My biggest concern was making sure it went to the "right" person if it were indeed something interesting, so this is a little bit of a relief. Had it been exceedingly rare, I might have hesitated to let it go and/or taken a longer time finding just the right person for this machine.

So kind! Thanks! Jen

Happy to assist! And, for the record, I am a firm believer that all these early phonographs are special, and your Columnia Grafonola looks to be in good condition and complete.... I would definitely take my time and make sure the right buyer appreciates it, is excited about it, and will give it a good home. Even though it is not worth really high numbers like the early/rare machines, it is still cool!

Take care!