The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

I believe the Edison Gem comprised only about 5% of total Edison sales in the United States. Although not an actual survey, I saw copies of orders which indicated about 90% of Edison sales were split between Standards and Homes and the remaining 10% split between Triumphs and Gems. Is this close to correct? I know the Gem is more frequently found in countries outside the United States. Why is this true? I know a Gem is generally noisier than other models but this is true here and abroad. The motor is not robust and playing time is limited but this is true anywhere. All human ears are very sensitive to changes in pitch and a Gem in good order plays fine. Why was it a better seller abroad? Thanks, Jerry Blais

Of the major pre-Amberola machines, I find the Standard to be the most common, followed by the Home, Fireside, Gem, and Triumph, in that order. However, I'd have to say the Amberola 30 is probably the most common of all.

I think the middle priced machines probably sold best. Keep in mind that Edison marketed the cylinder machines to the rural folks who would then have a practical and attractive piece of furniture to be proud of. Just speculation of course.

Was the Gem priced any lower than the comparable European machines? Or was it considered of higher quality?