The Talking Machine Forum — For All Antique Phonographs & Recordings

Being new to phonograpg collecting, I am trying to pick up one of each of the major player's machines. Then I can work with them all to decide which I like best and keep collecting from there. Any suggestions for what model Edisons might be best for a newbie? I know they are more complicated than Victors anyway but I would imagine there are differences between models too.

Thanks
Andrea

Complicated question:
- First you need to clarify cylinder or disc?
- If cylinder then internal or external horn?
- Want to play 2 or 4 min cylinders or both?
- If disc, then it's a bit easier
- About how much are you willing to spend?

Ah good. I didn't think to specify.

Ultimately I am going to want both a cylinder and a disc model. For the cylinder I would rather an external horn and I can't say it would matter either way about the length of the cylinder play.

That being said, I am pretty sure that the disc will be cheaper to start out with. And much closer to what I am working with so far. I am not sure what I want to spend I guess it just depends on what strikes me. I have gotten some pretty lucky breaks so I can worry about that when I find what I am looking for.

Starting with a disc then, I'd go for a laboratory model, C19 or C250. They are good runners, relatively cheap and replacement parts, should you need any, are plentiful. Plus that they sound great. There are many other options though too, at $300 or less, especially if you'd settle for a mahogany finish.

Thank you. That is very helpful. I know of a C-19 right now for $125 but it is mahogany and so are all but 1 of my other phonographs so maybe I will wait it out to find something a little different.

Don't be in a rush. There are plenty of them out there. If possible, I'd also consider spending a bit more money to get a nicer one that you won't tire of after a couple years. (That can be difficult, I know).

m0xiemama wrote:Ah good. I didn't think to specify.

Ultimately I am going to want both a cylinder and a disc model. For the cylinder I would rather an external horn and I can't say it would matter either way about the length of the cylinder play.

That being said, I am pretty sure that the disc will be cheaper to start out with. And much closer to what I am working with so far. I am not sure what I want to spend I guess it just depends on what strikes me. I have gotten some pretty lucky breaks so I can worry about that when I find what I am looking for.

If there is something you can get really cheap and rework it to beautiful appearance again..that's a thought too. It depends on what you got the most of..time or money.

When you are ready for a cylinder machine, I'd suggest a Model B Standard that has been converted to play four minute cylinders as well as two minute cylinders. The Standard was a wonderful design originally and parts are readily available. The ability to play two or four minute cylinders will allow you to pick interesting titles and know that you have the ability to play the cylinder when you get home. Jerry Blais