The Use of Historic Names

[Starkton]

Obviously my then indignation was not a good guide when I started this thread and I apologize for this. I would put it differently today but I keep my postings unchanged not to distort the subsequent discussion.

[estott]

Obviously my then indignation was not a good guide when I started this thread and I apologize for this. I would put it differently today but I keep my postings unchanged not to distort the subsequent discussion.

And I didn't realize how old the posts were or how bloody convoluted the thread became, my apology

[edisonphonoworks]

I think the real authority in this matter is the RIAA and Jonathan Lamy has chatted with me personally, they usually go after pirates you know; he left the conversation..... feeling his organization was the real Pirate!!! I am quoted in most college term papers on music piracy, look it up. However I am closing the book on this chapter, no need to reply, enough said. All I ever intended was as a curios 7 year old, I wanted to see how things work, I like science projects. Edison and history and all was just a boyhood curiosity, started with a letter to a dead inventor..... 1% inspiration 99% perspiration! I owe all this to a response from Leah Burt. Whom I think is related to Fred C Burt, Edison sound engineer.

[GeorgeDixon]

At least it is kept in America, if I did not keep the name alive, here,it would be used by someone from china, or India. How come a mention of it now? I have used the name since the mid 1990s, it was New North American Phonograph Co., in 1996,a few years after I was out of high school. I will have several articles, in the newsletter" In The Groove." On cylinder record manufacture. I started a column in 1990 when I was 16 called "The Antique Phonograph Corner." in a small publication called "The Collector" until 1997. I am Not a colector,but rather a hands on recording engineer, and service man. I have about ten talking machines, and. They were all basket cases as I am not able to afford pristine machines. I have thousands of hours of time, making wax formulations, molding blanks, and recording cylinders, it is a hobby, on a shoestring budget. I do most of my work for artists,museums and movies, theme parks, and the recording industry. I only make blanks for collectors, not so much recordings.

Alot of people appreciate the various good deeds you do Shawn for the benefit of many who are interested in the various aspects of phonographs. Keep it up

[GeorgeDixon]

With all due respect, this ad hominum attack was totally unwarranted and completely irrelevant. Other than one person, I don't believe anyone else here has been adversely affected by how Mr. Borri conducts his business and I'm sure many here have benefited by his research into, and construction of, early recordable sound media.

Bill

couldn't agree more

[HisMastersVoice]

I was seeing if there was a double standard. From what I see there is. Antagonize. Well I think that you guys antagonize me. I try to post fun things, and bring about a different perspective and then they are turned into bitter things. You all remind me of dealing with little children! Shawn Borri, North American Phonograph Company, NO Shawn NO! Victor Talking machine by a wealthy person, Yes Yes Yes!

Shawn,

The only person here I see acting like a child is you. You admitted in the post quoted above that you posted in this thread to see if there was a reaction, which is the definition of antagonization. Please take a moment to really think about why you might not get treated with respect sometimes. It might be how you often make yourself out to be a victim of some unknown atrocity or perhaps it's because you "threaten" us with things such as not selling blanks to us as if you're punishing a child. Regardless of the quality of your work and accomplishments, your interactions here are often quite arrogant.

I've said this before, but you have to remember that the research you post has a narrow audience, there are but a few interested in the chemistry and procedure behind making wax blanks. A topic about a Victor Talking Machine having more discussion than a report on the lead content of dictaphone blanks is neither surprising nor demeaning to you. You seem to think we are all out to get you for some reason, but in reality you are the one drawing attention to and creating these situations for the most part. I hate to involve myself in this any further, but enough is enough.

[Curt A]

I was seeing if there was a double standard. From what I see there is. Antagonize. Well I think that you guys antagonize me. I try to post fun things, and bring about a different perspective and then they are turned into bitter things. You all remind me of dealing with little children! Shawn Borri, North American Phonograph Company, NO Shawn NO! Victor Talking machine by a wealthy person, Yes Yes Yes!

Shawn,

The only person here I see acting like a child is you. You admitted in the post quoted above that you posted in this thread to see if there was a reaction, which is the definition of antagonization. Please take a moment to really think about why you might not get treated with respect sometimes. It might be how you often make yourself out to be a victim of some unknown atrocity or perhaps it's because you "threaten" us with things such as not selling blanks to us as if you're punishing a child. Regardless of the quality of your work and accomplishments, your interactions here are often quite arrogant.

I've said this before, but you have to remember that the research you post has a narrow audience, there are but a few interested in the chemistry and procedure behind making wax blanks. A topic about a Victor Talking Machine having more discussion than a report on the lead content of dictaphone blanks is neither surprising nor demeaning to you. You seem to think we are all out to get you for some reason, but in reality you are the one drawing attention to and creating these situations for the most part. I hate to involve myself in this any further, but enough is enough.

Brandon,

Then why did you choose to involve yourself further with this antagonizing comment??? You may not be interested in wax blanks or lead in Dictaphone blanks, but who made you the topic censor? If you choose to delete this post, it will just prove my point, so I am forwarding my comment to other people on the board.

Curt

[HisMastersVoice]

Brandon,

Then why did you choose to involve yourself further with this antagonizing comment??? You may not be interested in wax blanks or lead in Dictaphone blanks, but who made you the topic censor? If you choose to delete this post, it will just prove my point, so I am forwarding my comment to other people on the board.

Curt

First of all, I never stated I wasn't interested. Second of all, if you want to get technical, my delete button makes me the topic censor, not that I was saying Shawn's posts should be censored. Quite the contrary, I do find some of it interesting though I can't say I have much to comment about on the subject. My intention was to point out that such threads will not likely have an overwhelming number of conversation participants in comparison to a phonograph related thread. You clearly missed the point.

It's my job to try and get everyone to get along with each other and correct inappropriate behavior...such as digging up 3 year old arguments to see if anyone will bite again. I'm glad you were able to figure out how to forward your comment to other people on the board, though what strange behavior that doesn't really prove anything at all.

[briankeith]

Coffee anyone ??

[Chuck]