rust removal for phonograph parts

[Henry]

I favour the Black Treacle method , which I think is known as Molasses in the US:

Dissolve a big tin of black treacle in boiling water and fill up your container with the mixture and water.
Put your item in the container and come back in 3-4 weeks.
Incidentally the surface of the mixture will get a bit foamy so don't brim the container , and its probably best not left in the house unless the wife is on an extended holiday.
Take the item out of what is now quite a gungy mess and instantly rinse it clean and dry it.
Every trace of rust will be gone leaving only bare steel.
You now need to treat the steel with something (oil,grease,primer whatever) , as if its left in the air it will get surface rust again......
The treacle mixture doesn't harm paint either , so if you're trying to preserve whats left of an original finish its pretty damn good.

Steve

I suspect that it's the sulfur in the molasses that's doing the trick here. Possibly it forms a weak sulfuric acid in solution---any chemists out there? Please comment!

[GrafonolaG50]

Coca Cola for a few days and rub with a ball of tin or aluminum foil. I have used this multiple times on rusty, ground dug items.

[slippery]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CLaBFke ... e=youtu.be

[billybobbojim]

for over 40 years I have used apple cider vinegar and water

get a 5 gallon paint bucket (or the over priced homer bucket from home depot)

go to the grocery store and buy one gallon of apple cider vinegar 5% acidity
(if it says white vinegar any where on the bottle it wont work don't use it)

pour the whole gallon into the bucket and add 2 or three gallons of warm water to it

place the rusted items into the bucket and make Shure it is submerged.................

and let it set for overnight then retrieve the parts from the bucket and steel wool, scotch brite pad or small brass bristle brush the item under running water in the sink and most or all of the rust is gone if not put it back into the bucket for another day and continue to repeat until all the rust is gone.......

this is user friendly and non toxic