Off Brand Internal Horns

Discussions on Talking Machines & Accessories
Victrolacollector
Victor V
Posts: 2708
Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2011 11:23 pm
Location: NW Indiana VV-IV;

Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by Victrolacollector »

While Victrola's and Edison's mostly used metal horns to amplify their recordings, it seems as many off brand companies used a wood internal horn.

My Magnola Talking Machine, has a nice wood pyramid shaped horn with a volume control which opens and closes a flap inside the horn. The sound from the Magnola sounds so clear and warm compared to the more loud and "metal" sounding of the Victrola and Edison.

I like the Victrola and Edison, its just that they offer a different sound.

Does anyone prefer the Wood internal horns? Do you think an Edison Diamond Disc would have sounded better if Edison would have constructed a wooden horn in his machines?

estott
Victor Monarch
Posts: 4175
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:23 pm
Personal Text: I have good days...this might not be one of them
Location: Albany NY

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by estott »

Material has some effect on tone but the contour and construction - and the tone arm and soundbox- are the most important things. I've heard internal horn machines with boxy wood horns that sounded very poor and I've heard cheap machines with cast iron and sheet metal horns that sound great. I recently heard a machine with a horn made from a composition similar to cast plaster - it had a nice sound.

User avatar
ImperialGuardsman
Victor II
Posts: 215
Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2012 4:01 pm
Personal Text: Nothing like blaring Caruso out of your college dorm window...
Location: Oregon

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by ImperialGuardsman »

Victrolacollector wrote:While Victrola's and Edison's mostly used metal horns to amplify their recordings, it seems as many off brand companies used a wood internal horn.

My Magnola Talking Machine, has a nice wood pyramid shaped horn with a volume control which opens and closes a flap inside the horn. The sound from the Magnola sounds so clear and warm compared to the more loud and "metal" sounding of the Victrola and Edison.

I like the Victrola and Edison, its just that they offer a different sound.

Does anyone prefer the Wood internal horns? Do you think an Edison Diamond Disc would have sounded better if Edison would have constructed a wooden horn in his machines?

I think Edison horns sound fantastic. I think that metal was a good choice as Diamond Discs tend to have a warm tone anyway.
ImperialGuardsman

OTAPS (Oregon Territory Antique Phonograph Society) Member


~Also a member of Suscipe Domine and The High Road forums~

whoopinola
Victor I
Posts: 144
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2013 10:36 pm
Personal Text: Hmmmmmmmmm??
Location: Kingsville {Cedar Island} Ont

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by whoopinola »

It's interesting how these questions and statements can jog the brain back to things long forgotten...This string of posts makes me recall a horn found amungst a junk pile at a fellow collectors house...it was made of concrete , a good inch thick , probably weighed 40 pounds...designed for an internal horned machine...it appeared to be factory made.....any thoughts?

User avatar
FloridaClay
Victor VI
Posts: 3708
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:14 pm
Location: Merritt Island, FL

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by FloridaClay »

Edison experimented with some phonographs made of cement (the white one in this photo is an example), but I don't know if that included the horn or not or if any made it beyond the experimental stage and were actually sold. They must have been incredibly heavy.

Clay
Attachments
cement Edison.jpg
cement Edison.jpg (43.49 KiB) Viewed 2776 times
Arthur W. J. G. Ord-Hume's Laws of Collecting
1. Space will expand to accommodate an infinite number of possessions, regardless of their size.
2. Shortage of finance, however dire, will never prevent the acquisition of a desired object, however improbable its cost.

User avatar
VintageTechnologies
Victor IV
Posts: 1651
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 12:09 pm

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by VintageTechnologies »

I recall reading somewhere that Edison conducted tests to see if the material that phonograph horns were made from affected the tone. He even made some experimental horns from plaster. Edison concluded that the material was, ahem, immaterial. I own both wood and metal cygnet horns and cannot detect any difference, so if there really is any, it must be pretty subtle. Surface coatings inside the horn or thickness of the horn might possibly affect the sound. I think the curvature of the horn's flare is the most important factor affecting performance.

Moooperator
Victor I
Posts: 179
Joined: Fri Jan 09, 2009 12:55 am

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by Moooperator »

You can play a DD on a wood horn Brunswick but then you have the reproducer of a brunswick in the equation. I don't like playing DD on my brunswick. Somewhere I recall someone rigging a victor wood horn machine to play a DD and I think they had video too. Can't remember which collector did this though... anyone else recall this?

CarlosV
Victor V
Posts: 2134
Joined: Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:18 am
Location: Luxembourg

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by CarlosV »

Moo, the one I am aware of is not about playing DD, but similar: in the CAPS article linked below, the author Paul Dodington shows how to modify the orthophonic to play Pathé discs. Quite interesting!

http://www.capsnews.org/apn2011-3.htm

User avatar
FloridaClay
Victor VI
Posts: 3708
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:14 pm
Location: Merritt Island, FL

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by FloridaClay »

Carlos, thanks for the article. An interesting read.

Clay
Arthur W. J. G. Ord-Hume's Laws of Collecting
1. Space will expand to accommodate an infinite number of possessions, regardless of their size.
2. Shortage of finance, however dire, will never prevent the acquisition of a desired object, however improbable its cost.

User avatar
marcapra
Victor V
Posts: 2180
Joined: Thu Jun 28, 2012 12:29 am
Personal Text: Man who ride on tiger find it very difficult to dismount! Charlie Chan
Location: Temecula, CA

Re: Off Brand Internal Horns

Post by marcapra »

It's true that Edison DD horns are metal, but I thought most Victrola horns are made of wood. Most Victrolas I've owned including the Credenza have had wooden horns. The only Victrola with a metal horn that I own is the 8-35.

Post Reply