Who Is Midge Wall??

Phonofreak · Post by **Phonofreak** » Sat Jan 31, 2015 12:39 pm

I was looking on ebay and saw an Edison Fireside Model B with cygnet horn. The ebay No. is 231463130864. The seller is raving about the restoration by Midge Wall. Has anybody ever heard of that person? I like the comment on the posting about using the Diamond B to play 2 min. cylinders, Ugh

. And the H reproducer is an extra one. If someone can post the ebay listing, that way the membership can see it.
Harvey Kravitz

phonogal · Post by **phonogal** » Sat Jan 31, 2015 1:26 pm

Here's the link eBay Item #231463130864

stevel · Post by **stevel** » Sat Jan 31, 2015 1:48 pm

Doesn't refer to Midge Wall now.
Maybe it's himself, his other item is a restoration service!
Steve

phonogfp · Post by **phonogfp** » Sat Jan 31, 2015 8:20 pm

I don't know who Midge Wall is, but the photos show at least three different Firesides. Check out the grain patterns on the fronts.

George P.

Edisone · Post by **Edisone** » Sat Jan 31, 2015 9:23 pm

From a completed listing, here's an example of "Midge Wall" quality. The random Fireside pics, as pointed out by George, are even more questionable.

Player-Tone · Post by **Player-Tone** » Sat Jan 31, 2015 11:00 pm

stevel wrote:Doesn't refer to Midge Wall now.
Maybe it's himself, his other item is a restoration service!
Steve

It still does, it's down in the description which reads as follows:

"Near museum quality, Edison Fireside Model B phonograph complete with crane & Cygnet horn.

Phonograph has been completely professionally restored by Midge Wall, both mechanically & aesthetically. ALL ORIGINAL EDISON PARTS WERE USED DURING RESTORATION. Machine has been professionally sound-tested & includes two Edison reproducers--an Edison Model B & an Edison Model H 4-minute reproducer. Both of these reproducers have been completely cleaned, restored, rebuilt & have new styli installed.

This phonograph both looks & sounds absolutely magnificent! Wonderful addition to any collection.

Thanks for looking. "Genius is one percent inspiration and ninety-nine percent perspiration"....Thomas Alva Edison"

I can't help but wonder what makes her a "professional" after seeing that Exhibition rebuild posted above.

And as George pointed out, there are at least 3 machines posted in the pictures. Who knows what you are actually buying, this is a very risky auction in my opinion.

Post by **Roaring20s** » Sun Feb 01, 2015 1:38 am

https://www.etsy.com/ch-en/shop/OldPhon ... ut_leftnav

stevel · Post by **stevel** » Sun Feb 01, 2015 4:49 am

Player-Tone wrote:
stevel wrote:Doesn't refer to Midge Wall now.
Maybe it's himself, his other item is a restoration service!
Steve
It still does, it's down in the description

Bah , I swear that wasn't there when I read it.
I must be going mad.....

Steve

Cody K · Post by **Cody K** » Sun Feb 01, 2015 9:14 am

Kinda wanna wonder if she's a.) related to a certain Peter, b.) said Peter's drag alter ego, c.) trading on said good fellow's name, or d.) none of the above. Based on the pictures, I'm gonna say d., though c.'s a contender.

stevel · Post by **stevel** » Sun Feb 01, 2015 10:06 am

Roaring20s wrote:https://www.etsy.com/ch-en/shop/OldPhon ... ut_leftnav

Hah! So Midge Wall is in Columbus , Indiana and by an amazing coincidence so is the seller

Steev

Who Is Midge Wall??

Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??

Re: Who Is Midge Wall??