Edison horizontal carriage interchange

[rlh30edison]

Will an Edison Home horizontal carriage fit on an Edison Triumph D2 phonograph? Thanks for any advice.

[Phonofreak]

No it won't. The rods on the Home carriage is smaller than the rods on the Triumph. They are not interchangeable.
Harvey Kravitz

[rlh30edison]

I suspected as much. Thanks for your helpful reply, Harvey.

[long_island_phono]

Will an Edison Home horizontal carriage fit on an Edison Triumph D2 phonograph? Thanks for any advice.

If you have both a standard Triumph carriage and Home horizontal carriage then you can unscrew the horizontal carriage from the carriage tube and secure it on the Triumph carriage tube.

-Jake

[phonogfp]

If you have both a standard Triumph carriage and Home horizontal carriage then you can unscrew the horizontal carriage from the carriage tube and secure it on the Triumph carriage tube.

-Jake

The Home has a one-piece carriage, and cannot be used on a Triumph. The Triumph has a two-piece carriage/sleeve assembly, but it cannot be used on the Home because the back rods are different sizes. See photos below (please excuse the quick, low-light shots):

George P.

Home Carriage

Triumph Carriage

[long_island_phono]

The Home has a one-piece carriage, and cannot be used on a Triumph. The Triumph has a two-piece carriage/sleeve assembly, but it cannot be used on the Home because the back rods are different sizes. See photos below (please excuse the quick, low-light shots):

That is only one version of the horizontal carriage for the Home, George There is another version which has a separate carriage tube that can be removed. The carriage itself can be used with a Triumph carriage tube!

-Jake

[phonogfp]

Wow Jake, that's great! Thanks for showing that variation - - I don't think I've ever noticed one before.

George P.