Need some opinions on which machine to sell :/

[Tyler94]

We'll moneys tight so i figure i'm going to have to sell one of my machines as much as i hate to give it up so i need some opinions on which one to keep and which to sell.. i have a victrola vv-260 1923 model insides all re greased a week ago and a model vv-ix 1916 model also great working condition and all greased.i would like to keep the one with the most value so which to give up? thank you - Tyler btw i paid $165 for the vv-260 and $130 for the vv-IX.

[alang]

I would keep the one you like more. It's always difficult to speculate about future values, but historically console models are not as desireable by collectors. On the other hand, a IX is also quite a common machine, so no huge values there either.

Just by looking at your pictures I like the IX better, just because it is quarter sawn oak. But that is just my preference.

Good luck
Andreas

[gemering]

I agree with Andres.
I like the oak machine better, but that is my subjective opinion.
I don't think there's a great difference in value between the two machines.
Good luck,
Gene

[estott]

I would keep the IX and sell the 260 - BUT consoles like that just sit on the market with no takers. The IX is an attractive oak table model and would sell much better.

[Dave D]

Although the console model will be a a hard sell, you will be able to replace it very cheaply. I have never been able to sell one of those. Tall ones and table models sell, but I think those low ones just don't appeal to people like the other styles.
Dave D

[estott]

Also - the VV IX is a common machine in mahogany, but far less common in oak. You'd have some trouble replacing it.

[Tyler94]

Thank you everyone for the reply's helps greatly!

[phonojim]

As a matter of personal preference, I would sell the VV-260 because I don't like consoles, especially humpbacks. The VV-IX is a nice, full featured machine in a small package and is an unusual find in oak.

Jim

[mattrx]

I agree with the earlier opinions. I would keep the IX, from a collector's point of view. As a matter of fact most anyone would keep the IX as evidenced by the replies.

I am sure this has occurred to you, but if you need a higher price, and a quicker sale, the IX is the one to sell, though. It will sell much quicker for a decent value. The humpback will most likely take much longer to sell, only to sell for the same or less money. I do not own a IX, but have been looking for a good deal on one. I have had the chance to buy several humpbacks and never pulled the trigger.

My 2 cents.

Matt

[Jerry B.]

Tyler, If you are married, you could ask your wife. Mine is never wrong.